If you’ve been researching your next paddle, two names likely dominate your screen: Selkirk and Joola. These two brands are titans in the world of pickleball paddles, and each brings serious innovation, performance, and player loyalty.
So which one should you choose? In this head-to-head guide, we’ll break down the pros and cons of each paddle brand in 2025, cover their most popular models, and show you how to take either option to the next level with custom paddle bands, grip upgrades, and lead tape.
Let’s dive into the ultimate paddle showdown: Selkirk vs. Joola.
🏓 The Short Answer
Selkirk is known for its USA-made construction, control-oriented cores, and premium feel.
Joola is famous for power, spin, and pro-level design, especially with paddles like the Hyperion.
This Band has looked the best for both Joola and Selkirk - https://custompickleballbands.com/products/diamond-white-paddle-band
If you prefer spin-heavy power and a longer handle, Joola may be your winner.
If you want touch, control, and a more traditional feel, Selkirk has you covered.
But it doesn’t stop there — with the right customizations, any paddle can become your perfect paddle.
🔍 Selkirk Pickleball Paddles: Control, Craftsmanship & Comfort
🔧 Brand Overview
Selkirk is proudly made in Idaho, USA, and their paddles are engineered for durability, consistency, and comfort. They’re ideal for players who value precision, a soft feel, and versatile all-court performance.
⭐ Top Models in 2025:
-
Selkirk Vanguard Power Air: High-end performance with elite pop and spin
-
Selkirk Amped S2: Balanced control, wide face, and short handle
-
SLK Evo & Halo Series: Budget-friendly for new players
✅ Best for: Players who prioritize feel, finesse, and quality craftsmanship
🔥 Joola Pickleball Paddles: Power, Spin & Pro Design
🔧 Brand Overview
Joola exploded onto the scene by partnering with world #1 Ben Johns. Their paddles feature hyper-spin surfaces, long ergonomic handles, and are built for high-performance tournament play.
⭐ Top Models in 2025:
-
Joola Hyperion CFS 16: Ben Johns’ signature paddle – aggressive and stable
-
Joola Vision CGS: Great for two-handed backhands and lighter swings
-
Joola Essentials: Budget-friendly and solid for entry-level play
✅ Best for: Players who want spin, reach, and explosiveness
🛠 How to Customize Either Paddle for Maximum Performance
Regardless of which brand you choose, the truth is: a paddle straight out of the box isn’t fully optimized for you. That’s where paddle accessories come in — and they’re just as important as the paddle itself.
Here’s how to elevate any Joola or Selkirk paddle:
🎯 Add Lead Tape for Power and Stability
Whether you're playing with a Selkirk Amped or a Joola Hyperion, lead tape allows you to fine-tune your paddle's weight and balance to match your swing.
Benefits of lead tape:
-
Adds power to smashes and drives
-
Improves stability for volley blocks and dinks
-
Helps you adjust the feel to your personal tempo
Even just a few grams of lead tape at 3 and 9 o’clock can help you handle fast-paced rallies more effectively.
🖐 Upgrade the Grip for Better Feel and Control
Selkirk and Joola come with quality grips, but that doesn’t mean they’re right for your hand.
Upgrade your grip if you want:
-
More tackiness or sweat control
-
A cushioned feel that’s easier on your joints
-
A chance to match your style with cool colors or textures
Overgrips are affordable and easy to install — they can completely change how your paddle feels in your hand.
🏷 Add a Custom Pickleball Paddle Band for Identity & Style
Here’s a low-cost accessory that delivers big value: a custom pickleball paddle band. These silicone name bands wrap around your paddle throat and help you:
-
Identify your paddle instantly
-
Display your name, nickname, or team
-
Avoid mix-ups in group play or clubs
-
Add color and personal branding to your setup
These bands fit perfectly on both Selkirk and Joola paddles, and they’re a must-have for players who bring more than one paddle to the court.
🆚 Selkirk vs. Joola: Full Feature Comparison
| Feature | Selkirk | Joola |
|---|---|---|
| Build Quality | 🇺🇸 Made in USA | International, high quality |
| Control/Feel | Soft, consistent, wide sweet spot | Slightly firmer, more aggressive |
| Spin | Excellent with Vanguard series | Exceptional with Hyperion + textured faces |
| Power | Moderate to strong | Strong to elite (especially Hyperion) |
| Price Range | $$–$$$ | $$–$$$ |
| Warranty | Lifetime | 6–12 months |
| Best For | Finesse, consistency, touch | Aggression, spin, pace |
🤔 So Which Should You Choose?
-
Choose Selkirk if:
-
You prefer touch play, finesse, and a control-heavy game
-
You want a USA-made paddle with a wide sweet spot
-
You’re upgrading from a beginner paddle and want long-term durability
-
-
Choose Joola if:
-
You want power and spin right out of the box
-
You’re influenced by pro player setups (Ben Johns, etc.)
-
You like longer handles for two-handed shots or tennis crossover feel
-
Whichever you pick, make sure you own the paddle — not just by buying it, but by customizing it.
🎁 Bonus: Best Paddle Accessory Combo (for Any Brand)
Want the full upgrade kit?
🧩 Here’s our favorite 3-piece combo for Selkirk or Joola players:
This bundle gives you style, comfort, and power — no matter what brand is in your bag.
🗣 What Other Players Say
“I switched from Selkirk to Joola last year, but adding lead tape made the biggest difference. It felt like a whole new paddle.”
— Alex R., Tournament Player
“My Selkirk was perfect for touch, but the stock grip wore out fast. The grip and paddle band I got from CustomPickleballBands.com made it feel fresh again.”
— Lily M., 3.5 League Player
“No matter what paddle you use, get a band with your name on it. It’s a lifesaver in open play and just looks sick.”
— Bryan W., Weekend Warrior
✅ Final Verdict: Selkirk or Joola?
Truthfully, you can’t go wrong with either brand — but the paddle isn’t the final word. It’s the upgrades you add that make it yours.
-
💪 Use lead tape to match the paddle to your strength and style
-
🖐 Install a new grip to improve handling and comfort
-
🏷 Add a custom paddle band to make it unmistakably yours
🎯 Shop all accessories at CustomPickleballBands.com